Calming the Inner Critic and Getting to Work - Allegra Goodman
Thought Piece Response
When I was reading this article by Allegra Goodman, I
couldn’t help but think of myself when I used to free write a few years ago.
Goodman points out the critic in your head that keeps you from accomplishing
something truly masterful. I believe this “inner critic” is not only in our
head for writing, but it’s in our head when we’re in a stressful situation or
when we are unsure about which direction to take in life. I know for a fact
that this critic or “voice”, as I like to call it, gets in my head whenever I’m
pitching on baseball team. I constantly think to myself about the batter
hitting a homerun if I throw a fastball on an 3-2 or 2-2 count, or if I don’t
fake a move to first base the first base runner will steal second. It’s that
voice that plays tricks on us and keeps us from pursuing our dreams or moving
forward in our lives. In fact, all of my baseball coaches and trainers have
said baseball is a 90 percent mental game, and only a 10 percent physical game.
I like how Goodman relates this critic, or voice, to writers and their problems
with writing stories or new novels. She points out how old writers are dead and
that their ideas and masterpieces are left to the history books, and that we
should focus on ourselves and our writing, not the writing of a deceased
individual. This is a great point, and I find it a source of motivation for me
to think how the great inventors and genius’s of the past would never have
accomplished anything had they told themselves that something could not be
achieved. It’s also my belief that this world wouldn’t move forward and become
more advanced unless we had thinkers, writers, inventors, or engineers who
could tune out the “inner critic” and set out to accomplish extraordinary
things with great ideas. In my opinion, you should ignore the past and another
person’s accomplishments, because yours are still in the making and yours will
be unique and incomparable to another individuals achievements. This is my take on Goodman's "inner critic" when she is writing and how the "inner critic" can also be related to my life through baseball.
Sam, I like how you relate writing to Baseball. One of the things that intrigues me about teaching is finding out what sort of metaphors students use to describe their writing. Some that I am familiar with are "Writing is like pulling teeth," "Writing is like fingernails on a chalkboard," "Writing is like a slow painful death." MY metaphor is that writing is like....oh crap! I can't tell you that yet because I want to wait until after we play our fun analyze the instructor game! Well then, you can guess what mine might be. :-) But metaphor is helpful when trying to show others what we see, or create shared meaning through writing. I like that you use it and I hope you continue.
ReplyDelete--Mallory out!